Public and critical opinion on the song was notably divided:
: It features a "watery," quiet opening that builds into a lush, full-bodied chorus with layered vocals, muted bass, keyboards, and a steady rhythm track. Kenny Chesney - Tip Of My Tongue (Audio)
: Conversely, critics at The Singles Jukebox and Kyle's Korner found the lyrical metaphors, such as "salt and sugar," to be awkward or even "creepy". Some felt the "sensual" attempt felt unconvincing for Chesney's established persona. Kenny Chesney's New Song 'Tip of My Tongue' - Rolling Stone Public and critical opinion on the song was