The film follows Kate (Vera Farmiga) and John Coleman (Peter Sarsgaard), a couple struggling to repair their marriage and their home life following the tragic loss of their third child. In an attempt to fill the void, they visit a local orphanage and find themselves instantly drawn to (Isabelle Fuhrman), a polite, articulate, and artistic nine-year-old girl from Russia.
This twist recontextualized every uncomfortable moment in the film—from her "flirting" with John to her extreme violence—transforming the movie from a simple thriller into a grotesque, psychosexual drama. Legacy and The Prequel
She plays on John’s desire to move past Kate’s history with alcoholism, making Kate look unstable and paranoid.