[S1E6] There's No Place Like Homecoming

Chooses to go to the dance with Toby instead of Maya, leading to the episode's dangerous climax.

Struggles with her recent breakup with Ezra and spends much of the dance in awkward interactions with him while working a booth.

Believing Toby is Alison's killer, the girls text Emily a warning while she is alone with him in the chemistry lab. Panicked, Emily injures Toby and flees, knocking herself unconscious in the process.

Faces sabotage from her sister, Melissa, who tells Spencer's date (Alex) that she is only using him to spite their father.