Earlier historians viewed witchcraft trials as a product of "religious fanaticism," while later 20th-century historians (like Keith Thomas and Alan Macfarlane ) began adopting anthropological tools to show that trials were actually driven by "bottom-up" interpersonal tensions in local villages.
Research often centers on legal records, the role of gender (persecution of women), and the transition from medieval "magic" to modern secular "reason". Comparison of the Two Styles Anthropological School Historical School Primary Method Participant observation (Fieldwork) Archival research (Trial records) View of Witchcraft A functional social system A changing intellectual/legal concept Primary Subject Living non-Western societies Early Modern Europe/North America Explanation for Trials Relieves community stress Result of legal and theological shifts Modern Synthesis: The "New Collaboration" Two styles in the study of witchcraft - School ...
Witchcraft is a social mechanism used to explain "unfortunate events" (like a house collapsing or a crop failing) that lack an obvious cause. Earlier historians viewed witchcraft trials as a product
Anthropologists often distinguish between Witchcraft (an innate, often unconscious psychic power) and Sorcery (the learned use of spells, rituals, or medicines). 2. The Historical School (Historiographical Style) Two styles in the study of witchcraft - School ...
Earlier historians viewed witchcraft trials as a product of "religious fanaticism," while later 20th-century historians (like Keith Thomas and Alan Macfarlane ) began adopting anthropological tools to show that trials were actually driven by "bottom-up" interpersonal tensions in local villages.
Research often centers on legal records, the role of gender (persecution of women), and the transition from medieval "magic" to modern secular "reason". Comparison of the Two Styles Anthropological School Historical School Primary Method Participant observation (Fieldwork) Archival research (Trial records) View of Witchcraft A functional social system A changing intellectual/legal concept Primary Subject Living non-Western societies Early Modern Europe/North America Explanation for Trials Relieves community stress Result of legal and theological shifts Modern Synthesis: The "New Collaboration"
Witchcraft is a social mechanism used to explain "unfortunate events" (like a house collapsing or a crop failing) that lack an obvious cause.
Anthropologists often distinguish between Witchcraft (an innate, often unconscious psychic power) and Sorcery (the learned use of spells, rituals, or medicines). 2. The Historical School (Historiographical Style)
Copyright © 2026 Summit Venture
